Allora Collective

Get a Promotion or Launch a Job Search: Take Control of Your Career Growth – VIDEO

Allora Collective is a 1:1 career coaching practice founded in 2020, helping professionals navigate job searches, career transitions, leadership growth, and relocation through personalized coaching.
The end of the year is when a lot of people take stock. Maybe you got the promotion you were working toward. Maybe you were told “next cycle” again. Maybe your company just announced changes, and you are wondering what next year looks like for you.
In this video, Chez Jennings and I step back and look at career growth as a whole: how promotion and pay decisions really get made, how to build your case all year, what to do when the answer is “not yet,” and when growth means launching a job search instead. It follows our conversation on how to negotiate a job offer. That one covered the moment an offer arrives. This one covers how you get there, whether the next offer comes from your own company or a new one.
In the US, hiring slows down after Thanksgiving, and December is when many promotion, bonus and planning decisions land. That makes this a good time to think about what you want next year. Timestamps let you jump to any part of the video.

What growth means to you (1:52)

When people tell us they want growth, it can mean very different things. It might be more scope and ownership, new skills, a higher title or more pay. It might mean a different team, a different function or a different company. Start by naming which one you want, because each one leads to a different conversation.

How promotion and pay decisions really get made (2:32)

From the employer side, promotion and pay decisions are usually shaped in planning and budget meetings long before anyone sits down with you. Your manager has to make the case for you in rooms you are not in. I have done that for people on my own teams and coached managers to help them advocate for their teams successfully as well.
Chez gave an example of what typically happens before a role ever reaches recruiting (3:46):
  • Finance sets the budget first. Headcount and budget plans are set annually, quarterly or somewhere in between, then signed off by HR and handed to recruiting.
  • Succession planning comes next. Leaders ask whether anyone on the team is already exceeding expectations at their level and is ready for the next one.
  • Internal is often the budget-friendly choice. When someone strong is ready, promoting them usually costs less than hiring from outside.
  • Relationships matter. Beyond performance, it comes down to who you work closely with and whether you already have advocates.
Sometimes an external hire does make more sense, for example when a team needs industry or product experience it does not have, different leadership skills, or someone who has led a large migration or a move into a new market (6:08).
Many HR teams use methods like a “nine box” exercise to map who is ready for what, and to plan for the people they expect to leave after bonuses are paid or stock vests. And as automation changes how work gets done, leaders are rethinking which roles they need and which skills matter most (7:12).
The takeaway: your manager has to make the case for you, but it is up to you to build the case and hand it to them so they can deliver it.

A promotion conversation is still an interview (8:32)

Chez and I have seen many internal moves, especially in engineering, such as a tech lead or senior engineer move into people management. In Chez’s experience, most companies do not run a full interview loop for an internal promotion, but they do assess you. That often means at least one leadership-focused interview and at least one cross-functional interview, for example with a senior product leader asking how you prioritize, allocate resources and level up the people on your team. Recruiting still collects scorecards and puts a packet through for executive approval.
On pay, Chez has seen individual contributor to manager moves come with anywhere from a 10 to 20% increase at larger, well-funded tech companies, while a small startup may only be able to offer the title. And management is a different career track, not a reward. I have seen tech leads move into people management, decide it is not for them, and move back. That is a valid choice.

The 12-to-18-month check (11:04)

Here is advice we have given for years: if you are not moving up in scope, responsibility, title or compensation every year or year and a half, it is time to start looking at your options and take action. That does not mean you cannot stay at one company for a long time. It means you look after your own growth first, and you never wait for your manager to manage your promotion for you.

Build your case all year, not at review time (12:30)

Most companies have some version of a leveling matrix, KPIs or OKRs that show what you need to do to reach the next level. Ask your manager for it. Then track your own progress against it.
What a strong case includes:
  • A record of what you delivered, with numbers. Write it down when it happens: a sticky note, a note on your phone, whatever works. Once a month, move those notes into one place. If you wait until the end of the quarter, they get lost.
  • Evidence you are already doing parts of the next-level role (16:05). It is not just what you do. It is how what you do qualifies you for the next step.
  • Praise from other people (15:09). Chez’s tip: save the shout-outs, emails and messages from colleagues and leaders. A quote from someone in good standing is strong qualitative evidence in a promotion packet, and that person may become a reference.
  • A case your manager can repeat (16:39). Give your manager the data points and stories in a form they can pass along.
With clients, we use our Career Growth Planner for promotion business cases and performance review prep, worked into our 3-, 6- and 12-Month plans, to organize all of this and match it to the company’s leveling matrix.

Have a growth conversation every quarter (16:45)

Set a recurring meeting with your manager at least once a quarter that is only about your growth. Not a status update. A documented conversation about which boxes you have checked, what is next, and whether anything has changed on the company side. Companies add levels and restructure as they scale, and a new level between you and your goal changes what you need to get there.
How to open the first conversation (19:20):
  • Be honest about your goals. Someone 20 years into their career may care more about the work and the people than the title. Someone mid-career may want that senior title.
  • Ask what your manager needs to see. Sometimes your manager is limited, for example they can promote two of the eight people on the team this cycle.
  • Notice the signals. If your manager does not have answers, or tells you the growth is not going to happen there, that is useful information too.
  • Focus on your internal options first (22:12). Know where you stand before you decide to leave.
It is a conversation, not an ultimatum. And it is not arrogant to ask how you can grow (23:52). You are allowed to walk into the meeting and say, “I want to talk about my next level.” Asking for more does not mean you are ungrateful for what you have.
Chez added one more habit (22:56): keep a separate log of every growth conversation, the outcome and any timeline you were given. If you do start talking to recruiters, you can say, “My manager is supportive, but there is no timeline yet, and I am ready to move now.”

When the answer is "not yet" (24:45)

“Not yet” is the start of a plan, not the end of the conversation. Stay appreciative. Your manager may not be the decision maker, and promotion decisions often come from executive plans and budgets.
You do want to keep it accountable, so ask a few follow-up questions, not twenty:
  • When would be a good time to revisit this?
  • Is it on hold, or are we waiting on a decision?
  • What criteria do I still need to meet?
Then confirm it in writing. You can send something like this:
“Thank you for speaking with me about my growth today. I understand we don’t have a timeline yet for the promotion, and that eligibility will be considered [date]. As agreed, I’ll follow up with you next quarter so we can revisit it.”
If you freeze in the moment, that is fine. Send the questions in your follow-up email. Over time, your notes will show how long you have been waiting, who decides, and whether others were promoted while you were told “not yet.”
Watch for scope creep. Sometimes a company changes your responsibilities now and says the title or pay will follow. That is not unusual, but if you are suddenly doing the work of several people, you need to address it.

If the title can't move, ask for something else (28:09)

If the structure cannot change right now, you can still ask for:
  • A pay adjustment, or a change to your benefits.
  • A learning and development budget, certifications or continuing education.
  • Leadership coaching or a career coach.
  • More visible work that builds your case for next time.
Many employers cover career coaching as a benefit, often under learning and development, continuing education, leadership coaching, or career or professional development. Check your benefits, ask HR, and in many cases ask your manager for approval. We can invoice you and/or your employer directly or provide documentation for reimbursement.
Signs that “not yet” means “not here”: the answer keeps repeating, there is no date, and no one will discuss any alternative to the title or pay you asked for. If you feel dismissed, you are probably not imagining it. Some managers are simply uncomfortable giving bad news, so trust what you see over time.

Growth can mean a new role, a new company or a new city or country (29:45)

Growth is not only a higher title in the same seat. One client Chez coached moved from engineering into sales and is thriving. Early in my career, a company relocated me to Amsterdam, and living and working in another country was growth of its own. Chez has also seen people change jobs because life changed, for example moving closer to family when their employer would not support working from the new location (33:37).
Make the decision for yourself, not for your family, friends, former colleagues or influencers (30:49). For some people, the salary matters most. Others want purposeful work and accept the trade-offs, for example in nonprofit roles. What you want will change at different stages of your life, and that is okay.

Read the market before you decide (31:58)

The market plays a big part in whether internal or external growth makes more sense:
  • High demand, low supply. If your skills are in short supply, you likely have more options outside. Chez gave cybersecurity as an example: with more than four years of experience, you have a lot of choices right now.
  • Low demand, high supply. If there are fewer roles in your function, some people niche further with certifications and subject matter expertise, while others pivot, go back to school, start a business or build a side project alongside their career.
Chez wrote about the trade-offs she weighed in her own search in Offer Accepted: What 8 Weeks and 38 Applications Taught Me About the 2026 Tech Job Market. In her recruiting work, she often met people once they had exhausted their internal options and were going external.

Don't let fear make the decision (36:23)

We hear it all the time: “They’ll think I’m too old.” “I need this certification first.” “No one will hire me with a gap on my resume.” These are opinions, and everyone online has one. Test them with your own data before you decide an option is closed to you.
Your years of experience can be an asset, especially on a team that needs someone to lead through a difficult, high-pressure situation. And a gap is a story you can share. If you took time to travel, that can even make good small talk with an interviewer. If you stepped away to care for a family member, you can say as much or as little as you want. “I took a step back to take care of something personal” is enough.

Plan your growth for next year now (38:40)

By December, you will likely know whether you got the promotion, what your bonus looks like, and whether changes are coming early in the new year. That makes December a good month for strategy. Then in the first quarter, you can decide which options to test, which to go for, and which to set aside for now.
If you have a quiet hour over the holidays, Chez suggested writing down (40:48):
  • Your business impact. Revenue, user growth, money saved, or how you made work easier for your internal stakeholders.
  • What you want more of and less of. Which tasks do you avoid? Which do you love?
  • The scope you want next. More leadership, more ownership, mentorship, compensation, or new skills. If a tool keeps showing up in the job descriptions you want, start learning it. YouTube and online courses make that easier than ever.
  • Who decides, and what they need to hear. Know what your manager values, and what their manager and your executives value right now.
  • The date of your next growth conversation.
Don’t forget the people you have mentored, coached or helped grow (43:42). That counts too.

The takeaways

  • Promotion and pay decisions are often shaped in planning meetings before your review.
  • Your manager makes the case, but you build it. Track your results, with numbers, all year.
  • Have a documented growth conversation with your manager at least once a quarter.
  • “Not yet” needs criteria and a date. If neither comes, it may mean “not here.”
  • If the title can’t move, ask about pay, benefits, learning budget or coaching.
  • Growth can mean a new role, a new company or a new city or country. Decide for yourself, and read the market.
  • Use December to plan the growth you want next year.

Questions people ask

How often should you talk to your manager about a promotion?
At least once a quarter, in a meeting that is only about your growth. Bring your progress against the next level’s criteria, ask what has changed, and confirm what you agreed in a short follow-up email.
What should you do when a promotion is “not yet”?
Ask when you can revisit it, what criteria you still need to meet, and whether the decision is on hold or waiting on someone else. Confirm it in writing. If the title cannot move, ask about pay, benefits, a learning budget or coaching.
Should you leave your job to get promoted?
Start with your internal options so you know where you stand. If you have not grown in scope, title or pay in a year to a year and a half, there is no timeline, and your skills are in demand, an external search may be the faster path.

Plain definitions

  • Leveling matrix: a company’s description of what each job level is expected to do, used to decide promotions.
  • Succession planning: how leaders identify who is ready to step into the next role when someone is promoted or leaves.
  • Nine box: a grid HR teams use to map employees by performance and potential.
  • Promotion packet: the written case, often with scorecards and feedback, that goes to leadership for approval.
  • Internal mobility: moving to a new team, function or level inside your current company.

Plan your next step with us

If you want a clear read on where you stand and where you could go next, book a free consultation. It is a real conversation, with no pressure and no pitch.
In our 3-, 6- and 12-Month plans, we build your career stories with you in a Career Stories Game Plan, so your promotion case and your interview stories come from the same evidence. If you are established in your role and want a standing conversation through the year, our Advisory plan is built for that. Support is session-based: no custom searches and no continuous communication between sessions. Learn more about the Allora Coaching Plans, or read what clients say about working with us.
Individual results vary based on role, market, level and effort.

Watch the Full Conversation

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Posts

Share:

Allora Collective
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.